Melola Discovery

← Melola Discovery

Akses terbuka Jurnal

The Deconstruction of the Common Link Theory: Harald Motzki’s Methodological Critique of G.H.A. Juynboll’s Skepticism in Hadith Dating: Kritik Harald Motzki Terhadap Teori Common Link Juynboll

Diroyah : Jurnal Studi Ilmu Hadis · Vol. 10 No. 1 (2025) · hlm. 103–125

DOI
10.15575/diroyah.v10i1.47688
ISSN
2540-9069, 2540-9050
Terbit
2025-12-31
Penerbit
Prodi Ilmu Hadis Fakultas Ushuluddin UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung
Bahasa
eng
Lisensi
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0

Abstrak

The dating of hadith remains a contested frontier in the academic study of early Islam. G.H.A. Juynboll, refining Joseph Schacht’s legacy, advanced the common link theory, which treats the convergence point of transmission chains as the historical originator and probable fabricator of a tradition, while dismissing single strands as fictitious. This article reconstructs Harald Motzki’s methodological critique of that theory as articulated in Whither Hadith-Studies? and Dating Muslim Traditions, and subjects both positions to a dialectical reading. Using a qualitative library-research design with content, comparative, and interpretive analysis of primary sources, the study maps the scholarly factions involved and isolates the first principles on which each argument rests. The findings show that Juynboll’s identification of the common link with a forger relies on an argumentum e silentio and on a statistically unrealistic model of branching transmission, whereas Motzki reframes the common link as the first systematic collector and professional teacher, and grounds dating in the correlation of isnad and matn. The article further argues that the isnad-cum- matn method does not escape critique, since it confronts a structural circularity that recent scholarship has termed a principle of uncertainty. The contribution lies in offering Indonesian hadith studies a non-apologetic synthesis that neither absolutizes skepticism nor treats Motzki’s rebuttal as a closed verdict

Kata kunci

Jaringan kolaborasi para penulis

14 penulis · 25 tautan kepenulisan bersama

Arahkan kursor atau ketuk sebuah nama untuk menyorot rekan penulisnya. Klik dua kali untuk membuka halaman penulis.

  • Sunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung
  • Organisasi berbeda
  • Organisasi sama
  • Afiliasi tidak diketahui
  • Garis lebih tebal = lebih banyak artikel bersama · lingkaran lebih besar = lebih banyak artikel
Tampilkan sebagai tabel
Rekan penulisOrganisasiArtikel bersama
Reza PahleviSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Qabila SalsabilaSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Teti RatnasihSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Wahyudin DarmalaksanaSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Badri KhaerumanSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Mia Syahrina HanifaSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Wawan HernawanSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Cucu SetiawanSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Ayi RahmanSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1

Afiliasi berasal dari OpenAlex; metadata OAI-PMH jurnal tidak memuatnya. Penulis tanpa ID OpenAlex dicocokkan berdasarkan nama, sehingga dua orang bisa tergabung atau satu orang bisa terpisah.

Sumber metadata: OAI-PMH (metadata jurnal) https://journal.uinsgd.ac.id/index.php/Diroyah/oai, pertama di-harvest 7 Nov 2026, terakhir terlihat 16 Nov 2026.
Metadata asli (oai_dc)
<oai_dc:dc xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:oai_dc="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/  http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc.xsd">
	<dc:title xml:lang="en-US">The Deconstruction of the Common Link Theory: Harald Motzki’s Methodological Critique of G.H.A. Juynboll’s Skepticism in Hadith Dating: Kritik Harald Motzki Terhadap Teori Common Link Juynboll</dc:title>
	<dc:creator>Junus, Ihsan J</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>wahyudin, Dede Muhamad</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Najib, Mohammad</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Masrur, Ali</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Nur , Saifudin</dc:creator>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US">common link</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US">Harald Motzki</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US">G.H.A. Juynboll</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US"> isnad-cum- matn</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US">hadith dating</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US"> orientalist skepticism</dc:subject>
	<dc:description xml:lang="en-US">The dating of hadith remains a contested frontier in the academic study of early Islam. G.H.A. Juynboll, refining Joseph Schacht’s legacy, advanced the common link theory, which treats the convergence point of transmission chains as the historical originator and probable fabricator of a tradition, while dismissing single strands as fictitious. This article reconstructs Harald Motzki’s methodological critique of that theory as articulated in Whither Hadith-Studies? and Dating Muslim Traditions, and subjects both positions to a dialectical reading. Using a qualitative library-research design with content, comparative, and interpretive analysis of primary sources, the study maps the scholarly factions involved and isolates the first principles on which each argument rests. The findings show that Juynboll’s identification of the common link with a forger relies on an argumentum e silentio and on a statistically unrealistic model of branching transmission, whereas Motzki reframes the common link as the first systematic collector and professional teacher, and grounds dating in the correlation of isnad and  matn. The article further argues that the isnad-cum- matn method does not escape critique, since it confronts a structural circularity that recent scholarship has termed a principle of uncertainty. The contribution lies in offering Indonesian hadith studies a non-apologetic synthesis that neither absolutizes skepticism nor treats Motzki’s rebuttal as a closed verdict</dc:description>
	<dc:publisher xml:lang="en-US">Prodi Ilmu Hadis Fakultas Ushuluddin UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung</dc:publisher>
	<dc:date>2025-12-31</dc:date>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/article</dc:type>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion</dc:type>
	<dc:type xml:lang="en-US">Peer-reviewed Article</dc:type>
	<dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
	<dc:identifier>https://journal.uinsgd.ac.id/index.php/Diroyah/article/view/47688</dc:identifier>
	<dc:identifier>10.15575/diroyah.v10i1.47688</dc:identifier>
	<dc:source xml:lang="en-US">Diroyah : Jurnal Studi Ilmu Hadis; Vol. 10 No. 1 (2025):  Diroyah: Jurnal Studi Ilmu Hadis; 103-125</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2540-9069</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2540-9050</dc:source>
	<dc:language>eng</dc:language>
	<dc:relation>https://journal.uinsgd.ac.id/index.php/Diroyah/article/view/47688/16637</dc:relation>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en-US">Copyright (c) 2025 Ihsan J Junus;  Wahyudin; Mohammad Najib, Ali Masrur, Saifudin Nur </dc:rights>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en-US">https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0</dc:rights>
</oai_dc:dc>