Melola Discovery

← Melola Discovery

Akses terbuka Jurnal SINTA 1

Rethinking the Burden of Proof in Medical Malpractice Cases in Indonesia: A Case for Reversal

Yustisia · Vol. 15 No. 2 (2026) · hlm. 183–197

DOI
10.20961/yustisia.v15i2.110257
ISSN
2549-0907, 0852-0941
Terbit
2026-10-04
Penerbit
Faculty of Law, Universitas Sebelas Maret
Bahasa
eng
Lisensi
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0

Abstrak

Medical malpractice cases present distinctive evidentiary challenges because prosecutors may lack the specialized medical knowledge necessary to establish professional negligence, while crucial evidence, including medical records and information concerning clinical procedures, is largely controlled by healthcare providers. These circumstances create an evidentiary asymmetry that may impede effective access to justice for patients. This study examines whether and under what conditions the burden of proof may be shifted in criminal medical malpractice proceedings in Indonesia. It employs doctrinal legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches, focusing on Indonesia’s criminal procedure and health law frameworks. The study finds that a complete reversal requiring physicians to prove their innocence would raise concerns regarding the presumption of innocence. Nevertheless, a limited shift of the evidential burden may be justified where the prosecution establishes prima facie circumstances indicating gross medical negligence and the relevant evidence lies predominantly within the physician’s or healthcare provider’s control. In such circumstances, physicians may be required to demonstrate that medical interventions complied with applicable professional standards and procedures, while the ultimate burden of establishing criminal guilt remains with the prosecution. The study therefore proposes a limited and proportionate evidentiary-shifting model for gross medical negligence rather than a general reversal of the burden of proof in all medical malpractice cases

Kata kunci

Jaringan kolaborasi para penulis

28 penulis · 61 tautan kepenulisan bersama · 27 lintas organisasi

Arahkan kursor atau ketuk sebuah nama untuk menyorot rekan penulisnya. Klik dua kali untuk membuka halaman penulis.

  • Padjadjaran University
  • National University of Malaysia
  • University of Brawijaya
  • Bandung Islamic University
  • Jingdezhen Vocational University of Art
  • Universitas Jabal Ghafur
  • Institut Agama Islam Negeri Takengon
  • Organisasi lain
  • Afiliasi tidak diketahui
  • Organisasi berbeda
  • Organisasi sama
  • Afiliasi tidak diketahui
  • Garis lebih tebal = lebih banyak artikel bersama · lingkaran lebih besar = lebih banyak artikel
Tampilkan sebagai tabel
Rekan penulisOrganisasiArtikel bersama
Nazura Abdul ManapNational University of Malaysia2
Nur Khalidah DahlanNational University of Malaysia2
Hazar KusmayantiPadjadjaran University2
Siqi ChenAfiliasi tidak diketahui1
Wenze CaoJingdezhen Vocational University of Art1
Zhaoxun CaoJingdezhen Vocational University of Art1
Lastuti AbubakarPadjadjaran University1
Anita AfrianaPadjadjaran University1
Efa Laela FakhirahPadjadjaran University1
Sudarsono SudarsonoUniversity of Brawijaya1
Wahbi RahmanUniversity of Brawijaya1
Prija DjatmikaUniversity of Brawijaya1
Abdul MadjidUniversity of Brawijaya1
Efa Laela FakhriahPadjadjaran University1
Sherly Ayuna PutriPadjadjaran University1
Andhita Nurul KhasanahBandung Islamic University1
Ihsana Sabriani BorualogoBandung Islamic University1
Ali MubarakBandung Islamic University1
Mohammad Hamidi MasykurUniversity of Brawijaya1
Dede KaniaSunan Gunung Djati State Islamic University Bandung1
Cao ZhaoxunJingdezhen Vocational University of Art1
Chen SiqiNational University of Malaysia1
Zamre Mohd ZahirNational University of Malaysia1

Afiliasi berasal dari OpenAlex; metadata OAI-PMH jurnal tidak memuatnya. Penulis tanpa ID OpenAlex dicocokkan berdasarkan nama, sehingga dua orang bisa tergabung atau satu orang bisa terpisah.

Sumber metadata: OAI-PMH (metadata jurnal) https://jurnal.uns.ac.id/yustisia/oai, pertama di-harvest 10 Nov 2026, terakhir terlihat 16 Nov 2026.
Metadata asli (oai_dc)
<oai_dc:dc xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:oai_dc="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/  http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc.xsd">
	<dc:title xml:lang="en-US">Rethinking the Burden of Proof in Medical Malpractice Cases in Indonesia: A Case for Reversal</dc:title>
	<dc:creator>Hatta, Muhammad</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Rajamanickam, Ramalinggam</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Khairunnisa, Cut</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Mahdi, Umar</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Gusfira, Nofil</dc:creator>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en-US">Burden of Proof; Medical Malpractice; Medical Negligence; Criminal Evidence</dc:subject>
	<dc:description xml:lang="en-US">Medical malpractice cases present distinctive evidentiary challenges because prosecutors may lack the specialized medical knowledge necessary to establish professional negligence, while crucial evidence, including medical records and information concerning clinical procedures, is largely controlled by healthcare providers. These circumstances create an evidentiary asymmetry that may impede effective access to justice for patients. This study examines whether and under what conditions the burden of proof may be shifted in criminal medical malpractice proceedings in Indonesia. It employs doctrinal legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches, focusing on Indonesia’s criminal procedure and health law frameworks. The study finds that a complete reversal requiring physicians to prove their innocence would raise concerns regarding the presumption of innocence. Nevertheless, a limited shift of the evidential burden may be justified where the prosecution establishes prima facie circumstances indicating gross medical negligence and the relevant evidence lies predominantly within the physician’s or healthcare provider’s control. In such circumstances, physicians may be required to demonstrate that medical interventions complied with applicable professional standards and procedures, while the ultimate burden of establishing criminal guilt remains with the prosecution. The study therefore proposes a limited and proportionate evidentiary-shifting model for gross medical negligence rather than a general reversal of the burden of proof in all medical malpractice cases</dc:description>
	<dc:publisher xml:lang="en-US">Faculty of Law, Universitas Sebelas Maret</dc:publisher>
	<dc:contributor xml:lang="en-US">Universitas Malikussaleh</dc:contributor>
	<dc:date>2026-10-04</dc:date>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/article</dc:type>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion</dc:type>
	<dc:type xml:lang="en-US"></dc:type>
	<dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
	<dc:identifier>https://jurnal.uns.ac.id/yustisia/article/view/110257</dc:identifier>
	<dc:identifier>10.20961/yustisia.v15i2.110257</dc:identifier>
	<dc:source xml:lang="en-US">Yustisia; Vol 15, No 2 (2026): August 2026; 183-197</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2549-0907</dc:source>
	<dc:source>0852-0941</dc:source>
	<dc:language>eng</dc:language>
	<dc:relation>https://jurnal.uns.ac.id/yustisia/article/view/110257/pdf</dc:relation>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en-US">Copyright (c) 2026 Muhammad Hatta</dc:rights>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en-US">http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0</dc:rights>
</oai_dc:dc>