Melola Discovery

← Melola Discovery

Open access Journal

Criminal Liability for Circumcision Malpractice: Ibn Qayyim’s Jurisprudence and Indonesian Criminal Law

Legitimasi: Jurnal Hukum Pidana dan Politik Hukum · Vol. 15 No. 1 (2026) · pp. 115–134

DOI
10.22373/lg.v15i1.32019
ISSN
2579-5104, 2088-8813
Published
2026-06-24
Publisher
Faculty of Sharia and Law, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh
Language
eng
License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

Abstract

This article analyzes criminal liability for malpractice committed by circumcision (khitan) practitioners, as outlined by Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, and examines its relevance to positive law in Indonesia. The study is motivated by fundamental differences in the determination of criminal liability between classical Islamic legal perspectives and national law. This research is normative legal research employing a statute approach and a conceptual approach. Data were collected through library research, including primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials such as statutory regulations, the works of Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, and relevant scholarly literature. The data were analyzed using a descriptive-analytical method that integrated perspectives on positive law and Islamic normative law. The findings indicate that, according to Ibn Qayyim, a circumcision practitioner must possess both professional competence and a valid practice license. A competent and licensed practitioner is not subject to criminal liability for patient harm in the absence of intentional wrongdoing, whereas an unqualified and unlicensed practitioner may be held criminally liable. In contrast, under Indonesian positive law, criminal liability is not solely based on intent (mens rea) but also encompasses negligence and recklessness that result in harm; thus, a practitioner may still be held criminally liable despite having competence and a valid license. Accordingly, Ibn Qayyim’s view appears less relevant within the framework of Indonesian positive law regarding criminal liability. Nevertheless, his emphasis on strict requirements for competence and licensing has preventive value, helping minimize malpractice and enhance professional standards in medical practice.

Keywords

Collaboration network of the authors

11 authors · 18 co-authorship links · 6 across different organisations

Hover or tap a name to highlight its co-authors. Double-click to open the author's page.

  • Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry
  • Sunan Kalijaga State Islamic University Yogyakarta
  • Universiti Tenaga Nasional
  • Different organisations
  • Same organisation
  • Affiliation unknown
  • Thicker line = more joint articles · bigger circle = more articles
Show as table
Co-authorOrganisationJoint articles
Iskandar IskandarUniversitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry2
Rahul HusniUniversitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry2
Lastrina LastrinaUniversitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry1
Muhammad MaulanaUniversitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry1
Bustamam UsmanUniversitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry1
Emk AlidarUniversitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry1
Ahmad Bunyan WahibSunan Kalijaga State Islamic University Yogyakarta1
Muhammad Jihadul HayatSunan Kalijaga State Islamic University Yogyakarta1

Affiliations come from OpenAlex; journal OAI-PMH metadata carries none. Authors without an OpenAlex ID are matched by name, which can merge or split people.

Metadata source: OAI-PMH (metadata jurnal) https://jurnal.ar-raniry.ac.id/index.php/legitimasi/oai, first harvested 7 Nov 2026, last seen 7 Nov 2026.
Original metadata (oai_dc)
<oai_dc:dc xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:oai_dc="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/  http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc.xsd">
	<dc:title xml:lang="en">Criminal Liability for Circumcision Malpractice: Ibn Qayyim’s Jurisprudence and Indonesian Criminal Law</dc:title>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">Maulidar, Rona</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">Syah, Yuhasnibar</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">binti Awang, Nurulbahiah </dc:creator>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Criminal Liability</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Medical Malpractice</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Circumcision</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Indonesian Criminal Law</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Criminal Liability </dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Circumcision Malpractice</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Ibn Qayyim’s Jurisprudence </dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Indonesian Criminal Law</dc:subject>
	<dc:description xml:lang="en">This article analyzes criminal liability for malpractice committed by circumcision (khitan) practitioners, as outlined by Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, and examines its relevance to positive law in Indonesia. The study is motivated by fundamental differences in the determination of criminal liability between classical Islamic legal perspectives and national law. This research is normative legal research employing a statute approach and a conceptual approach. Data were collected through library research, including primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials such as statutory regulations, the works of Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, and relevant scholarly literature. The data were analyzed using a descriptive-analytical method that integrated perspectives on positive law and Islamic normative law. The findings indicate that, according to Ibn Qayyim, a circumcision practitioner must possess both professional competence and a valid practice license. A competent and licensed practitioner is not subject to criminal liability for patient harm in the absence of intentional wrongdoing, whereas an unqualified and unlicensed practitioner may be held criminally liable. In contrast, under Indonesian positive law, criminal liability is not solely based on intent (mens rea) but also encompasses negligence and recklessness that result in harm; thus, a practitioner may still be held criminally liable despite having competence and a valid license. Accordingly, Ibn Qayyim’s view appears less relevant within the framework of Indonesian positive law regarding criminal liability. Nevertheless, his emphasis on strict requirements for competence and licensing has preventive value, helping minimize malpractice and enhance professional standards in medical practice.</dc:description>
	<dc:publisher xml:lang="en">Faculty of Sharia and Law, Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh</dc:publisher>
	<dc:date>2026-06-24</dc:date>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/article</dc:type>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion</dc:type>
	<dc:type xml:lang="en">Peer-reviewed Article</dc:type>
	<dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
	<dc:identifier>https://jurnal.ar-raniry.ac.id/index.php/legitimasi/article/view/32019</dc:identifier>
	<dc:identifier>10.22373/lg.v15i1.32019</dc:identifier>
	<dc:source xml:lang="en">Legitimasi: Jurnal Hukum Pidana dan Politik Hukum; Vol. 15 No. 1 (2026); 115-134</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2579-5104</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2088-8813</dc:source>
	<dc:source>10.22373/lg.v15i1</dc:source>
	<dc:language>eng</dc:language>
	<dc:relation>https://jurnal.ar-raniry.ac.id/index.php/legitimasi/article/view/32019/13165</dc:relation>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en">Copyright (c) 2026 Rona Maulidar, Yuhasnibar Syah, Nurulbahiah  binti Awang</dc:rights>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en">http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0</dc:rights>
</oai_dc:dc>