Melola Discovery

← Melola Discovery

Open access Journal SINTA 1

Judicial Review of Constitutional Amendments: Comparative Experiences and Their Relevance to Indonesia

Jambe Law Journal · Vol. 8 No. 2 (2025) · pp. 611–646

DOI
10.22437/hrajxb07
ISSN
2598-795X, 2598-7925
Published
2025-12-31
Publisher
Faculty of Law, Jambi University
Language
eng
License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0

Abstract

Constitutional amendments, while essential to democratic adaptability, increasingly generate a paradox in which the power to amend risks eroding the foundational identity and normative coherence of constitutional orders. In jurisdictions undergoing intensive constitutional change, the absence of effective constraints on amendment power has enabled forms of constitutional transformation that are formally legal yet substantively unconstitutional. This article aims to examine comparative practices of constitutional amendment review and to assess their relevance for the future design of Indonesia’s constitutional system. Employing a historical–comparative approach, the study analyzes how apex and constitutional courts in selected jurisdictions have developed doctrines to limit and review constitutional amendments. This article advances three original contributions. First, it reconceptualizes constitutional amendment review not merely as a technical instrument of judicial control, but as a mechanism for safeguarding constitutional identity and higher-order constitutional norms. Second, it situates Indonesia’s unamendable clause on the unitary state and the philosophical status of Pancasila within the global doctrine of unconstitutional constitutional amendments, demonstrating their latent justiciability. Third, it offers a normative model for empowering the Indonesian Constitutional Court to act as the institutional guardian of constitutional identity, thereby transforming amendment review into a principled framework for preserving constitutional integrity in periods of political and constitutional flux

Keywords

Collaboration network of the authors

18 authors · 37 co-authorship links · 21 across different organisations

Hover or tap a name to highlight its co-authors. Double-click to open the author's page.

  • Padjadjaran University
  • Universitas Gorontalo
  • Abu Dhabi University
  • Tadulako University
  • State University of Gorontalo
  • Universitas Galuh
  • Riau University
  • Other organisations
  • Affiliation unknown
  • Different organisations
  • Same organisation
  • Affiliation unknown
  • Thicker line = more joint articles · bigger circle = more articles
Show as table
Co-authorOrganisationJoint articles
Novendri Mohamad NggiluState University of Gorontalo3
Roy Marthen MoontiUniversitas Gorontalo2
Ramdhan KasimUniversitas Gorontalo1
Evi NoviawatiUniversitas Galuh1
Andi Inar SahabatAffiliation unknown1
Efa Laela FakhriahPadjadjaran University1
Dwi Bintang SatrioPadjadjaran University1
Artaji ArtajiPadjadjaran University1
Geofani Milthree SaragihUniversitas Sumatera Utara1
Mexsasai IndraRiau University1
Sarifuddin SudingAffiliation unknown1
I Gde Pantja AstawaPadjadjaran University1
Ade YuliasihPadjadjaran University1
Maya KhaterAbu Dhabi University1

Affiliations come from OpenAlex; journal OAI-PMH metadata carries none. Authors without an OpenAlex ID are matched by name, which can merge or split people.

Metadata source: OAI-PMH (metadata jurnal) http://jlj.unja.ac.id/index.php/home/oai, first harvested 9 Nov 2026, last seen 9 Nov 2026.
Original metadata (oai_dc)
<oai_dc:dc xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:oai_dc="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/  http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc.xsd">
	<dc:title xml:lang="en">Judicial Review of Constitutional Amendments: Comparative Experiences and Their Relevance to Indonesia</dc:title>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">Tumuhulawa, Arifin</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">Nggilu, Novendri Mohmad</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">Yassine, Chami</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator xml:lang="en">Tampubolon, Muhammad Hatta Roma</dc:creator>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Judicial Review</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Constitutional Amendment</dc:subject>
	<dc:subject xml:lang="en">Constitutional Identity</dc:subject>
	<dc:description xml:lang="en">Constitutional amendments, while essential to democratic adaptability, increasingly generate a paradox in which the power to amend risks eroding the foundational identity and normative coherence of constitutional orders. In jurisdictions undergoing intensive constitutional change, the absence of effective constraints on amendment power has enabled forms of constitutional transformation that are formally legal yet substantively unconstitutional. This article aims to examine comparative practices of constitutional amendment review and to assess their relevance for the future design of Indonesia’s constitutional system. Employing a historical–comparative approach, the study analyzes how apex and constitutional courts in selected jurisdictions have developed doctrines to limit and review constitutional amendments. This article advances three original contributions. First, it reconceptualizes constitutional amendment review not merely as a technical instrument of judicial control, but as a mechanism for safeguarding constitutional identity and higher-order constitutional norms. Second, it situates Indonesia’s unamendable clause on the unitary state and the philosophical status of Pancasila within the global doctrine of unconstitutional constitutional amendments, demonstrating their latent justiciability. Third, it offers a normative model for empowering the Indonesian Constitutional Court to act as the institutional guardian of constitutional identity, thereby transforming amendment review into a principled framework for preserving constitutional integrity in periods of political and constitutional flux</dc:description>
	<dc:publisher xml:lang="en">Faculty of Law, Jambi University</dc:publisher>
	<dc:date>2025-12-31</dc:date>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/article</dc:type>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion</dc:type>
	<dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
	<dc:identifier>https://jlj.unja.ac.id/index.php/home/article/view/370</dc:identifier>
	<dc:identifier>10.22437/hrajxb07</dc:identifier>
	<dc:source xml:lang="en">Jambe Law Journal; Vol. 8 No. 2 (2025); 611-646</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2598-795X</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2598-7925</dc:source>
	<dc:language>eng</dc:language>
	<dc:relation>https://jlj.unja.ac.id/index.php/home/article/view/370/111</dc:relation>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en">Copyright (c) 2025 Jambe Law Journal</dc:rights>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en">https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0</dc:rights>
</oai_dc:dc>