Melola Discovery

← Melola Discovery

Open access Journal SINTA 1

From Non-Judicial Mediation to Multi-Forum Litigation: Jurisdictional Fragmentation in Waqf Land Conflicts in Indonesia

Syariah Jurnal Hukum dan Pemikiran · Vol. 26 No. 2 (2026) · pp. 267–296

DOI
10.18592/sjhp.v26i2.20535
ISSN
2549-001X, 1412-6303
Published
2026-10-26
Publisher
Universitas Islam Negeri Antasari Banjarmasin
Language
eng
License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0

Abstract

English

Disputes over waqf land may arise not only from its waqf status but also from institutional relationships, cooperation agreements, and land administration issues. This study examines the escalation of a dispute between two educational foundations in Central Java, originating from educational management cooperation, proceeding through non-judicial mediation, and ultimately developing into litigation across multiple judicial forums. Using a qualitative socio-legal design and law in books and law in action approaches, data were collected from court decisions, party documents, semi-structured interviews, and field observations. Interviews conducted from October 2025 to March 2026 involved judges, mediators, advocates, foundation trustees and chairs, and witnesses. Data were analyzed through thematic analysis and conflict trajectory analysis. The findings reveal that the dispute primarily stemmed from unclear provisions concerning the duration and termination of the cooperation agreement and differing interpretations of the consequences of converting the asset into waqf. Non-judicial mediation failed because the participating representatives lacked substantive decision-making authority. The dispute subsequently entered multiple judicial forums: the Ontowiryo Foundation (pseudonym) pursued contractual claims before the District Court under Case No. 479/Pdt.G/2024/PN.Smg, while the Jadidah Foundation challenged administrative errors in the waqf certificate before the Administrative Court (PTUN), naming BPN and the Ontowiryo Foundation as an intervening defendant. The proceedings continued through appeal and cassation. The study demonstrates that legal pluralism and differentiated judicial authority allow distinct dimensions of a single conflict to be addressed in separate forums, resulting in jurisdictional fragmentation. Clear cooperation agreements, accurate waqf administration, and dispute resolution involving actors with substantive decision-making authority are therefore essential to prevent escalation into litigation.

Indonesian

Artikel ini menganalisis eskalasi sengketa tanah wakaf antara dua lembaga pendidikan di Indonesia yang bermula dari mediasi non-yudisial dan berkembang menjadi litigasi multi-forum di Pengadilan Negeri, Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara, hingga Mahkamah Agung. Fokus utama penelitian ini adalah mengidentifikasi faktor penyebab konflik, dinamika kegagalan mediasi, preferensi yurisdiksi para pihak, serta implikasi yuridis dari pluralisme hukum dalam sistem peradilan Indonesia. Penelitian menggunakan pendekatan socio-legal dengan memadukan statute approach dan case approach melalui analisis putusan pengadilan, wawancara mendalam dengan para pihak, mediator, hakim, tokoh agama, serta observasi lapangan di lokasi sengketa. Kerangka teoritik yang digunakan adalah teori Sistem Hukum Lawrence M. Friedman dan pluralisme hukum John Griffiths. Temuan utama menunjukkan bahwa kelemahan perjanjian kerja sama, ketidakjelasan jangka waktu kontrak, perubahan status aset menjadi wakaf, serta kegagalan representasi dalam mediasi menjadi pemicu utama konflik. Selain itu, pilihan forum litigasi mencerminkan praktik forum shopping akibat fragmentasi yurisdiksi antara peradilan agama, peradilan umum, dan peradilan administrasi. Artikel ini menegaskan perlunya harmonisasi kewenangan peradilan, penguatan tata kelola wakaf, dan optimalisasi mekanisme penyelesaian sengketa berbasis rekonsiliasi.

Collaboration network of the authors

14 authors · 32 co-authorship links · 18 across different organisations

Hover or tap a name to highlight its co-authors. Double-click to open the author's page.

  • Walisongo State Islamic University
  • Universiti Teknologi MARA
  • State University of Semarang
  • Flinders University
  • Institut Ilmu Al-Qur'an An-Nur Yogyakarta
  • Universitas Wahid Hasyim
  • Affiliation unknown
  • Different organisations
  • Same organisation
  • Affiliation unknown
  • Thicker line = more joint articles · bigger circle = more articles
Show as table
Co-authorOrganisationJoint articles
A. Hasan Asy'ari UlamaiAffiliation unknown1
Sukendar SukendarWalisongo State Islamic University1
Priyambudi SulistiyantoFlinders University1
Luthfi RahmanWalisongo State Islamic University1
Ratna Aryati NurjanahInstitut Ilmu Al-Qur'an An-Nur Yogyakarta1
Ali ImronWalisongo State Islamic University1
Azmi MuttaqinUniversitas Wahid Hasyim1
Mohd Razlan AhmadUniversiti Teknologi MARA1

Affiliations come from OpenAlex; journal OAI-PMH metadata carries none. Authors without an OpenAlex ID are matched by name, which can merge or split people.

Metadata source: OAI-PMH (metadata jurnal) http://jurnal.uin-antasari.ac.id/index.php/syariah/oai, first harvested 10 Nov 2026, last seen 16 Nov 2026.
Original metadata (oai_dc)
<oai_dc:dc xmlns="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:oai_dc="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc/  http://www.openarchives.org/OAI/2.0/oai_dc.xsd">
	<dc:title xml:lang="en-US">From Non-Judicial Mediation to Multi-Forum Litigation: Jurisdictional Fragmentation in Waqf Land Conflicts in Indonesia</dc:title>
	<dc:creator>Saifullah, Muhammad</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Tolkah, Tolkah</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Mamduh, Muhammad Faizul</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Sulistyono, Agus</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Nurkhanif , Muhammad</dc:creator>
	<dc:creator>Saidon, Refeah</dc:creator>
	<dc:description xml:lang="en-US">Disputes over waqf land may arise not only from its waqf status but also from institutional relationships, cooperation agreements, and land administration issues. This study examines the escalation of a dispute between two educational foundations in Central Java, originating from educational management cooperation, proceeding through non-judicial mediation, and ultimately developing into litigation across multiple judicial forums. Using a qualitative socio-legal design and law in books and law in action approaches, data were collected from court decisions, party documents, semi-structured interviews, and field observations. Interviews conducted from October 2025 to March 2026 involved judges, mediators, advocates, foundation trustees and chairs, and witnesses. Data were analyzed through thematic analysis and conflict trajectory analysis. The findings reveal that the dispute primarily stemmed from unclear provisions concerning the duration and termination of the cooperation agreement and differing interpretations of the consequences of converting the asset into waqf. Non-judicial mediation failed because the participating representatives lacked substantive decision-making authority. The dispute subsequently entered multiple judicial forums: the Ontowiryo Foundation (pseudonym) pursued contractual claims before the District Court under Case No. 479/Pdt.G/2024/PN.Smg, while the Jadidah Foundation challenged administrative errors in the waqf certificate before the Administrative Court (PTUN), naming BPN and the Ontowiryo Foundation as an intervening defendant. The proceedings continued through appeal and cassation. The study demonstrates that legal pluralism and differentiated judicial authority allow distinct dimensions of a single conflict to be addressed in separate forums, resulting in jurisdictional fragmentation. Clear cooperation agreements, accurate waqf administration, and dispute resolution involving actors with substantive decision-making authority are therefore essential to prevent escalation into litigation.</dc:description>
	<dc:description xml:lang="id-ID">Artikel ini menganalisis eskalasi sengketa tanah wakaf antara dua lembaga pendidikan di Indonesia yang bermula dari mediasi non-yudisial dan berkembang menjadi litigasi multi-forum di Pengadilan Negeri, Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara, hingga Mahkamah Agung. Fokus utama penelitian ini adalah mengidentifikasi faktor penyebab konflik, dinamika kegagalan mediasi, preferensi yurisdiksi para pihak, serta implikasi yuridis dari pluralisme hukum dalam sistem peradilan Indonesia. Penelitian menggunakan pendekatan socio-legal dengan memadukan statute approach dan case approach melalui analisis putusan pengadilan, wawancara mendalam dengan para pihak, mediator, hakim, tokoh agama, serta observasi lapangan di lokasi sengketa. Kerangka teoritik yang digunakan adalah teori Sistem Hukum Lawrence M. Friedman dan pluralisme hukum John Griffiths. Temuan utama menunjukkan bahwa kelemahan perjanjian kerja sama, ketidakjelasan jangka waktu kontrak, perubahan status aset menjadi wakaf, serta kegagalan representasi dalam mediasi menjadi pemicu utama konflik. Selain itu, pilihan forum litigasi mencerminkan praktik forum shopping akibat fragmentasi yurisdiksi antara peradilan agama, peradilan umum, dan peradilan administrasi. Artikel ini menegaskan perlunya harmonisasi kewenangan peradilan, penguatan tata kelola wakaf, dan optimalisasi mekanisme penyelesaian sengketa berbasis rekonsiliasi.</dc:description>
	<dc:publisher xml:lang="en-US">Universitas Islam Negeri Antasari Banjarmasin</dc:publisher>
	<dc:date>2026-10-26</dc:date>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/article</dc:type>
	<dc:type>info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion</dc:type>
	<dc:type xml:lang="en-US">Peer-reviewed Article</dc:type>
	<dc:format>application/pdf</dc:format>
	<dc:identifier>http://jurnal.uin-antasari.ac.id/index.php/syariah/article/view/20535</dc:identifier>
	<dc:identifier>10.18592/sjhp.v26i2.20535</dc:identifier>
	<dc:source xml:lang="en-US">Syariah: Jurnal Hukum dan Pemikiran; Vol. 26 No. 2 (2026); 267-296</dc:source>
	<dc:source xml:lang="id-ID">Syariah: Jurnal Hukum dan Pemikiran; Vol 26 No 2 (2026); 267-296</dc:source>
	<dc:source>2549-001X</dc:source>
	<dc:source>1412-6303</dc:source>
	<dc:language>eng</dc:language>
	<dc:relation>http://jurnal.uin-antasari.ac.id/index.php/syariah/article/view/20535/5201</dc:relation>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en-US">Copyright (c) 2026 Muhammad Saifullah, Tolkah Tolkah, Muhammad Faizul Mamduh, Agus Sulistyono, Muhammad Nurkhanif , Refeah Saidon</dc:rights>
	<dc:rights xml:lang="en-US">http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0</dc:rights>
</oai_dc:dc>