Open access Journal SINTA 3
COMBINATION OF CONTENT VALIDITY INDEX AND FUZZY DELPHI FOR EXPERT VALIDATION OF A THREE-TIER MATHEMATICS LEARNING DIFFICULTIES DIAGNOSTIC ASSESSMENT
BAREKENG: Jurnal Ilmu Matematika dan Terapan · Vol. 20 No. 4 (2026) · pp. 3425–3438
- ISSN
- 2615-3017, 1978-7227
- Published
- 2026-08-24
- Publisher
- PATTIMURA UNIVERSITY
- Language
- eng
Abstract
The persistent challenges in identifying mathematics learning difficulties require diagnostic instruments that are not only valid but also capable of accurately capturing students’ conceptual understanding, reasoning, and confidence. This study aims to compare the Content Validity Index (CVI) and the Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM) in expert validation of a three-tier diagnostic assessment for mathematics learning difficulties. Theoretically, the study integrates classical content validation theory with fuzzy logic-based expert consensus analysis to strengthen the methodological rigor of instrument development. The research involved five doctoral-level experts who evaluated 21 diagnostic items. The CVI results yielded an excellent S-CVI/Ave value of 0.97, indicating high content validity, while the FDM results confirmed 20 of 21 items met the validity thresholds (d ≤ 0.2, consensus ≥ 75%, A ≥ 0.5). A key finding shows that the CVI provides clear numerical validation, whereas the FDM captures linguistic uncertainty and confidence variations among experts, producing a more comprehensive validation outcome. The integration of both methods offers a robust framework for expert validation that enhances interpretive depth and accuracy. This study contributes to the field of mathematics education by presenting a validated, reliable, and pedagogically meaningful diagnostic instrument for identifying students’ misconceptions and reasoning patterns.
Collaboration network of the authors
34 authors · 80 co-authorship links · 35 across different organisations
Hover or tap a name to highlight its co-authors. Double-click to open the author's page.
- State University of Jakarta
- National Research and Innovation Agency
- Sebelas Maret University
- Hasanuddin University
- State University of Semarang
- Universitas Islam Negeri Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau
- Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University Jakarta
- Other organisations
- Affiliation unknown
- Different organisations
- Same organisation
- Affiliation unknown
- Thicker line = more joint articles · bigger circle = more articles
Show as table
| Co-author | Organisation | Joint articles |
|---|---|---|
| Gunarhadi Gunarhadi | Sebelas Maret University | 2 |
| Mahdiyah Mahdiyah | State University of Jakarta | 2 |
| St. Aflahah | National Research and Innovation Agency | 2 |
| AM Saifullah Aldeia | National Research and Innovation Agency | 2 |
| Shila Majid Ardiyani | Sebelas Maret University | 1 |
| Mayu Syahwela | Universitas Islam Negeri Sultan Syarif Kasim Riau | 1 |
| Yofran Hengki Ndoluanak | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Gaguk Margono | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Sabrianto Aswad | Hasanuddin University | 1 |
| Titien Haryani | Hasanuddin University | 1 |
| Marniati Ramli | Hasanuddin University | 1 |
| Syamsuddin Syamsuddin | Hasanuddin University | 1 |
| Yoga Dwi Arianda | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Ichsan Kamal | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Wawan Supriadi | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Luthfi Ilham Ramdhani | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Soeharno Soeharno | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Evi Refni | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Baso Marannu | National Research and Innovation Agency | 1 |
| Munasprianto Ramli | Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University Jakarta | 1 |
| Vina Septiana Windyasari | Universitas Islam Syekh Yusuf | 1 |
| Tegar Shalahuddin Ruhutama | Al-Azhar University | 1 |
| Risma Renata | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Mahmud Yunus | State University of Jakarta | 1 |
| Dyah Rini Indriyanti | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Parmin Parmin | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Nila Lestari | IPB University | 1 |
| Gusti Yarmi | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Loes Witteveen | Van Hall Larenstein University of Applied Sciences | 1 |
| Rico Lie | Wageningen University & Research | 1 |
| Berti Dyah Permatasari | Sebelas Maret University | 1 |
Affiliations come from OpenAlex; journal OAI-PMH metadata carries none. Authors without an OpenAlex ID are matched by name, which can merge or split people.