Open access Journal
The Dynamics of Secondary Rules in Constitutional Adjudication: An Analysis of H.L.A. Hart’s Theory on Indonesia’s Constitutional Court Decision Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023
The Indonesian Journal of International Clinical Legal Education · Vol. 8 No. 1 (2026) · pp. 111–138
- ISSN
- 2721-8368
- Published
- 2026-07-03
- Publisher
- Universitas Negeri Semarang
- Language
- eng
Abstract
This study aims to examine the constitutional validity and theoretical implications of Constitutional Court Decision Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023 concerning the age limit for presidential and vice-presidential candidates in Indonesia. The main issues raised are the inconsistency of legal reasoning and the shift in the role of the Constitutional Court, which acts as a positive legislator, triggering a substantive legitimacy crisis behind formal validity. The research method employed is a juridical-normative approach with a qualitative doctrinal orientation. The analysis was conducted using H.L.A. Hart’s theoretical instrument regarding the dual rule system to dissect the relationship between primary and secondary rules. The research findings indicate that procedurally, the decision is a valid application of the rule of adjudication and the rule of change, as it is sourced from the highest rule of recognition, namely the 1945 Constitution. However, a substantial rift exists between the internal aspects of legal authority and the external aspects of public acceptance due to the open-ended nature of the legal language used by the judge. This study concludes that although the decision has binding legal force, this phenomenon indicates an expansion of secondary authority that can threaten legal certainty if not limited by objective parameters. The results of this study contribute to clinical legal education by enhancing understanding of the dynamics of norm change through judicial channels during the democratic transition process.
Keywords
Collaboration network of the authors
40 authors · 115 co-authorship links · 31 across different organisations · showing the 40 most connected
Hover or tap a name to highlight its co-authors. Double-click to open the author's page.
- State University of Semarang
- Universitas Wahid Hasyim
- Universitas Langlangbuana
- Diponegoro University
- Universiti Teknologi MARA
- Sapienza University of Rome
- Direktorat Jenderal Imigrasi
- Other organisations
- Affiliation unknown
- Different organisations
- Same organisation
- Affiliation unknown
- Thicker line = more joint articles · bigger circle = more articles
Show as table
| Co-author | Organisation | Joint articles |
|---|---|---|
| Yuli Prasetyo Adhi | Diponegoro University | 9 |
| Saru Arifin | State University of Semarang | 7 |
| Rahmawati Mohd Yusoff | Universiti Teknologi MARA | 7 |
| Muhammad Shidqon Prabowo | Universitas Wahid Hasyim | 5 |
| Arif Hidayat | State University of Semarang | 5 |
| Slamet Sumarto | State University of Semarang | 4 |
| Tegar Islami Putra | State University of Semarang | 4 |
| Mohammad Reza Fachruddin | State University of Semarang | 4 |
| Indah Sri Utari | State University of Semarang | 3 |
| Arif Nur Hidayat | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Triska Rahmatul Aini | Sapienza University of Rome | 2 |
| Rini Fidiyani | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Asep Rozali | Affiliation unknown | 2 |
| Abraham Abraham | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Windi Agustin | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Masyitha Aulia Arifa | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Pujiono Pujiono | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Ratih Damayanti | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Duhita Driyah Suprapti | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Pujiono Pujiono | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Dani Muhtada | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Ristina Yudhanti | State University of Semarang | 2 |
| Gianefi Safitri | Direktorat Jenderal Imigrasi | 1 |
| Natal Kristiono | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Anis Widyawati | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Shofriya Qonitatin Abidah | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Panggih Kusuma Ningrum | Université Bourgogne Franche-Comté | 1 |
| Kun Retno Handayani | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Elyna Noor Dina Nazla | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Yurida Zakky Umami | Universitas Wahid Hasyim | 1 |
| Ratih Damayanti | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Eko Mukminto | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Bayangsari Wedhatami | State University of Semarang | 1 |
| Jafar Sidik | Universitas Langlangbuana | 1 |
| Deni Haspada | Universitas Langlangbuana | 1 |
Affiliations come from OpenAlex; journal OAI-PMH metadata carries none. Authors without an OpenAlex ID are matched by name, which can merge or split people.