Open access Journal
Legitimate Interests Under the GDPR and International Human Rights Law: A Proportionality Critique
Uti Possidetis: Journal of International Law · Vol. 7 No. 3 (2026) · pp. 449–468
- ISSN
- 2721-8333, 2721-8031
- Published
- 2026-09-28
- Publisher
- Faculty of Law, Universitas Jambi
- Language
- en
Abstract
English
Background: The concept of legitimate interests as a basis for the lawful processing of personal data occupies a unique and vulnerable position in international data protection law. The GDPR formally adopts this concept under Article 6(1)(f); however, its operationalization raises fundamental questions regarding the adequacy of the doctrine of proportionality in protecting informational self-determination as a human right under Article 17 of the ICCPR and regional human rights instruments. Methodology: This article employs a normative juridical method integrating international human rights law analysis, the doctrine of proportionality, comparative legal analysis, and doctrinal analysis of judicial decisions. Purpose: This study critically examines whether the formal proportionality model underlying the legitimate interests framework in the GDPR can protect fundamental rights under conditions of radical informational asymmetry, surveillance capitalism, and data colonialism that characterize the global digital economy. Findings: The analysis shows that the GDPR proportionality model, although sophisticated, contains structural weaknesses when applied to diverse socio-economic contexts. The proposed framework consists of a mandatory three-step test, a Legitimate Interests Assessment (LIA), an anti-catch-all doctrine, and an allocation of the burden of proof based on international human rights law. Originality/Novelty: This article advances three arguments: first, the normative uncertainty of the GDPR legitimate interests clause challenges its adequacy as an international model; second, the transplantation of a proportionality-based balancing model without adequate institutional prerequisites risks creating accountability gaps; third, in the context of surveillance capitalism as data colonialism, a rights-first proportionality framework is required.
Indonesian
Latar Belakang: Artikel ini mencoba mengkritisi bagaimana konsep kepentingan hukum yang sah sebagai dasar legitimasi pemrosesan data pribadi yang unik dan rentan dalam arsitektur tata kelola data Indonesia. Undang-Undang Nomor 27 Tahun 2022 tentang Perlindungan Data Pribadi secara formal mengadopsi konsep tersebut melalui Pasal 20 huruf (f), namun tanpa disertai definisi, mekanisme pengujian operasional, alokasi beban pembuktian, maupun hak keberatan yang dapat dijalankan. Ketidakpastian normatif ini bukan sekadar kelemahan teknis, melainkan menimbulkan pertanyaan konstitusional fundamental. Metodologi: Artikel ini menggunakan metode yuridis normatif yang mengintegrasikan analisis konstitusional, doktrin proporsionalitas, perbandingan hukum (GDPR), dan analisis doktrinal putusan pengadilan untuk merumuskan parameter normatif kepentingan yang sah di Indonesia Tujuan: Penelitian ini secara kritis mengkaji apakah model proporsionalitas formal yang mendasari sebagian besar kerangka kepentingan yang sah — termasuk GDPR — dapat melindungi hak-hak fundamental dalam kondisi ketimpangan informasional radikal, kapitalisme surveilans, dan kolonialisme data yang menjadi ciri ekonomi digital Global South. Temuan: temuan yang diusulkan terdiri atas uji tiga tahap wajib, persyaratan penilaian kepentingan yang sah, doktrin anti-tangkap-semua (anti-catchall), dan alokasi beban pembuktian yang berpijak pada konstitusi yang ditawarkan tidak semata sebagai solusi bagi Indonesia, tetapi sebagai kontribusi terhadap debat akademik yang lebih luas tentang apakah model proporsionalitas liberal mampu melindungi hak-hak fundamental dalam kondisi ketimpangan informasional yang radikal. Orisinalitas/Keunikan: Artikel ini mengajukan tiga argumen, Pertama ketidakpastian normatif klausul kepentingan yang sah dalam UU PDP bukan sekadar kekurangan dalam perumusan legislatif, melainkan suatu defisiensi konstitusional yang bersifat struktural. Kedua, ambisi transplantasi model keseimbangan berbasis proporsionalitas GDPR ke dalam ekonomi digital berkembang tanpa prasyarat kelembagaan yang memadai. Ketiga, dalam konteks kapitalisme surveilans sebagai kolonialisme data, model keseimbangan secara konstitusional dan teoretis tidak mencukupi, yang diperlukan adalah kerangka proporsionalitas yang mendahulukan hak (rights-first proportionality) yang berangkat dari praduga konstitusional yang mengutamakan penentuan-diri informasional.
Keywords
Collaboration network of the authors
40 authors · 102 co-authorship links · 5 across different organisations · showing the 40 most connected
Hover or tap a name to highlight its co-authors. Double-click to open the author's page.
- Universitas Jambi
- Mulawarman University
- Affiliation unknown
- Different organisations
- Same organisation
- Affiliation unknown
- Thicker line = more joint articles · bigger circle = more articles
Show as table
| Co-author | Organisation | Joint articles |
|---|---|---|
| Akbar Kurnia Putra | Universitas Jambi | 5 |
| Budi Ardianto | Universitas Jambi | 4 |
| Fauzi Syam | Universitas Jambi | 2 |
| Nelli Herlina | Universitas Jambi | 2 |
| Indriya Fatni | Affiliation unknown | 2 |
| Lili Naili Hidayah | Universitas Jambi | 2 |
| Bernard Sipahutar | Universitas Jambi | 2 |
| Mochammad Farisi | Affiliation unknown | 2 |
| Evalina Alissa | Universitas Jambi | 2 |
| Helmi Helmi | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Nopyandri Nopyandri | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Sahuri Lasmadi | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| M. Zulva Aulia | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Harry Setya Nugraha | Mulawarman University | 1 |
| Lili Naili Hidayah | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Raffles Raffles | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Raffles Raffles | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Ivan Fauzani Raharja | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Eko Nuriyatman | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Rustian Mushawirya | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Elizabeth Siregar | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Dwi Suryahartati | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Firdaus Abu Bakar | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Wahyu Satya Wibowo | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Eva Juliana Purba | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Eva Juliana Purba | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Akbar Kurnia Putra | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Nurul Istiana Hasan | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Nurul Istiana Hasan | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Ririn Ardila | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| ak Putra | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Ririn Ardila | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Muhammad Ariq Abir Jufri | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Muhammad Ariq Abir Jufri | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Akbar Chusnein | Affiliation unknown | 1 |
| Akbar Chusnein | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
| Novianti Novianti | Universitas Jambi | 1 |
Affiliations come from OpenAlex; journal OAI-PMH metadata carries none. Authors without an OpenAlex ID are matched by name, which can merge or split people.